Recommendations

Movies and shows like Widow's Bay

Our engine crosses vibes, genres and moods to keep Widow's Bay going. See the Widow's Bay page →

These 18 titles extend Widow's Bay through mood and genre. The selection runs from 1959 to 2023. The highest rated is Teen Wolf (8.5). 6 of them are on Hulu, Prime Video.

Stranger Things
★ 8.4
Stranger Things2016

In common: supernatural horror, horror

American Horror Story
★ 8.1
American Horror Story2011

In common: supernatural, supernatural horror

FROM
★ 7.9
FROM2022

Same decade, the 2020s · In common: horror, supernatural horror

Supernatural
★ 8.2
Supernatural2005

In common: supernatural, horror

Death in Paradise
★ 7.5
Death in Paradise2011

Also comedy · In common: island

Lost
★ 8.0
Lost2004

In common: island

Black Mirror
★ 8.3
Black Mirror2011

In common: horror

Teen Wolf
★ 8.5
Teen Wolf2011

Also comedy · In common: supernatural

The Strain
★ 7.5
The Strain2014

In common: horror

Dark Shadows
★ 7.3
Dark Shadows1966

In common: curse, supernatural

Buffy the Vampire Slayer
★ 8.1
Buffy the Vampire Slayer1997

Also comedy · In common: supernatural

Grimm
★ 8.3
Grimm2011

In common: supernatural

Fringe
★ 8.1
Fringe2008

In common: supernatural

Silo
★ 7.9
Silo2023

Same decade, the 2020s

Shetland
★ 7.5
Shetland2013

In common: island