Log in

Recommendations

Movies and shows like Supernatural

Our engine crosses vibes, genres and moods to keep Supernatural going. See the Supernatural page →

These 18 titles extend Supernatural through mood and genre. The selection runs from 1959 to 2024. The highest rated is Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood (8.9). 7 of them are on Netflix, Hulu.

Stranger Things
★ 8.4
Stranger Things2016

Also mystery · In common: horror, monster

Jujutsu Kaisen
★ 8.6
Jujutsu Kaisen2020

Also sci-fi & fantasy, action · In common: bromance, demon

American Horror Story
★ 8.1
American Horror Story2011

Also mystery · In common: horror, supernatural

Charmed
★ 7.4
Charmed1998

Also mystery, sci-fi & fantasy · In common: demon, witch

Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
★ 8.9
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood2009

Also action · In common: brother brother relationship, supernatural

The Vampire Diaries
★ 7.8
The Vampire Diaries2009

Also sci-fi & fantasy, supernatural · In common: witch, supernatural

Buffy the Vampire Slayer
★ 8.1
Buffy the Vampire Slayer1997

In common: monster, supernatural

The Twilight Zone
★ 8.5
The Twilight Zone1959

Also mystery · In common: horror

Xena: Warrior Princess
★ 7.6
Xena: Warrior Princess1995

Also action · In common: dark fantasy, supernatural

The Witcher
★ 7.9
The Witcher2019

Also action · In common: monster, dark fantasy

Angel
★ 7.9
Angel1999

In common: monster, dark fantasy

Z Nation
★ 7.3
Z Nation2014

Also mystery, action

The Walking Dead
★ 7.9
The Walking Dead2010

Also sci-fi & fantasy, action · In common: horror

The X-Files
★ 8.4
The X-Files1993

Also mystery · In common: supernatural

Wednesday
★ 8.3
Wednesday2022

Also mystery · In common: witch, dark fantasy

The 100
★ 7.9
The 1002014

Also action

The Originals
★ 8.6
The Originals2013

Also mystery · In common: witch

Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story
★ 7.6
Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story2024

In common: brother brother relationship