Recommendations

Movies and shows like Amazing Stories

Our engine crosses vibes, genres and moods to keep Amazing Stories going. See the Amazing Stories page →

These 18 titles extend Amazing Stories through mood and genre. The selection runs from 1966 to 2024. The highest rated is Wizards Beyond Waverly Place (8.9). 6 of them are on Hulu, Prime Video.

Buffy the Vampire Slayer
★ 8.1
Buffy the Vampire Slayer1997

Also comedy · In common: magic, supernatural

Ghosts
★ 8.0
Ghosts2021

Also comedy · In common: ghost

Dark Shadows
★ 7.3
Dark Shadows1966

In common: supernatural, ghost

Teen Wolf
★ 8.5
Teen Wolf2011

Also comedy · In common: supernatural

Dinosaurs
★ 7.8
Dinosaurs1991

Also comedy, family

Shadowhunters
★ 7.6
Shadowhunters2016

In common: magic, supernatural

Outlander
★ 8.2
Outlander2014

In common: time travel, magic

Henry Danger
★ 8.3
Henry Danger2014

Also comedy, family

The X-Files
★ 8.4
The X-Files1993

In common: supernatural

Xena: Warrior Princess
★ 7.6
Xena: Warrior Princess1995

In common: supernatural

H2O: Just Add Water
★ 7.8
H2O: Just Add Water2006

Also family · In common: supernatural

Quantum Leap
★ 8.0
Quantum Leap1989

Same decade, the 1980s · In common: time travel

Doctor Who
★ 7.6
Doctor Who2005

In common: time travel