Recommendations

Movies and shows like Old

Our engine crosses vibes, genres and moods to keep Old going. See the Old page →

These 18 titles extend Old through mood and genre. The selection runs from 1960 to 2026. The highest rated is Psycho (8.4). 8 of them are on HBO Max, Peacock.

Smile 2
★ 6.6
Smile 22024

Also mystery · In common: escape, body horror

The Substance
★ 7.1
The Substance2024

In common: body horror

Psycho
★ 8.4
Psycho1960

Also mystery · In common: murder

Sinister
★ 6.7
Sinister2012

Also mystery · In common: murder

Arrival
★ 8.0
Arrival2016

Also mystery

Evil Dead Burn
★ 6.8
Evil Dead Burn2026

In common: body horror

Black Phone 2
★ 6.7
Black Phone 22025

In common: murder

Pearl
★ 7.2
Pearl2022

In common: murder

It Follows
★ 6.6
It Follows2015

Also mystery · In common: beach

Hereditary
★ 7.4
Hereditary2018

Also mystery · In common: murder

Lee Cronin's The Mummy
★ 8.0
Lee Cronin's The Mummy2026

Also mystery · In common: body horror

Se7en
★ 8.4
Se7en1995

Also mystery · In common: murder

Backrooms
★ 7.1
Backrooms2026

Also mystery · In common: body horror

Bring Her Back
★ 7.3
Bring Her Back2025

In common: body horror

The Thing
★ 8.3
The Thing1982

Also mystery · In common: body horror